is the flagship publication of the IEEE — the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences. Our articles, podcasts, and infographics inform our readers about developments in technology, engineering, and science.
Enjoy more free content and benefits by creating an account
Saving articles to read later requires an IEEE Spectrum account
The Institute content is only available for members
Downloading full PDF issues is exclusive for IEEE Members
's Digital Edition is exclusive for IEEE Members
Following topics is a feature exclusive for IEEE Members
Adding your response to an article requires an IEEE Spectrum account
Create an account to access more content and features on
, including the ability to save articles to read later, download Spectrum Collections, and participate in conversations with readers and editors. For more exclusive content and features, consider
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to all of Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits.
Learn more →
“A lie gets halfway
around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes.” That’s a great line, but who originally said it? Was it Mark Twain, always good for an epigram, or the oft-quoted Winston Churchill? According to
The New York Times
, it’s an
of something written three centuries ago by famed satirist Jonathan Swift: “Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it.”
“Truth is the first casualty of war.” (Classical playwright
or California statesman
?) Given truth’s obvious vulnerabilities, we should be doing more to protect it when we send it out to do battle. But having constructed a technological apparatus that disseminates information instantaneously and globally without regard to its veracity, we shouldn’t be surprised that this apparatus has left us drowning in lies.
“First we shape our tools, thereafter our tools shape us.” (
?) Our copy-and-paste notions of truth and factuality likely have their roots in the early Web, which was intended initially only to link resources stored across a heterogeneous range of computers at
, the European Organization for Nuclear Research. The particle physicists’ tool soon helped everyone to share information about everything. But the Web’s hyperlinks inevitably create an impenetrable thicket of pointers, from one resource to another to another to another until it becomes nearly impossible to discern an ultimate source of truth. The Web created a global, hyperlinked document space, paradoxically making the truth more obscure than ever.
Two decades before the Web, hypertext pioneer
offered another model: Rather than just reference sources, include them. More subtle than a simple copy-and-paste operation, Nelson’s approach allows one document to embed the content of another via a link to a portion of the source document. In such a system nothing needs to be copied. The referring document “transcludes” a portion of the material found in the source document.
Transclusion allows for the creation of hypertext documents that are themselves the assembly of other hypertext documents that are themselves the assembly of still more hypertext documents. While any document can contain original content, it simultaneously serves as a window onto other documents, allowing viewers to reach into and through the references, all the way back to their primary sources. Transclusion could have created a Web built on a set of unimpeachable, universally accepted sources of information.
Served up by content-management systems that algorithmically compose documents from multiple sources, the modern Web gradually converged with Nelson’s vision for transclusion—with one key difference: The Web offers no single source of truth, nor any ultimate reference to a set of trusted sources. Instead, everything points to everything else (or to itself), which tends to make the Web appear to be fuller and more authoritative than it really is. That helps explain why conspiracy theories like
are so difficult to root out.
It would only take a few subtle changes to nudge the Web away from the shifting sands of links and plant it firmly in the real world of universally accepted facts. The nature of these authoritative sources will be fought over, naturally, as fierce rivals battle it out to set the terms for defining the truth. Yet where we can build consensus, humanity would possess “a truth universally acknowledged”—to borrow a line that we can all agree belongs to Jane Austen.
This article appears in the December 2020 print issue as “The Web’s Lurking Lies.”
founded, in 1991, the world's first consumer virtual reality startup. And he and others developed the Virtual Reality Modeling Language (
). He also founded the first company to use VRML to deliver streaming 3D entertainment over the Web. He currently serves as Entrepreneur-in-Residence at the University of Sydney's
. In addition to being an engineer and a teacher, Pesce is also a popularizer. In 2005, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation invited Pesce to become a panelist and judge on the television series "The New Inventors." In 2011 Pesce published his sixth book, The Next Billion Seconds. In 2014, Pesce and
launched the podcast
This Week in Startups Australia
. Later Pesce started
The Next Billion Seconds
podcast. And since 2014, he's been
a columnist for The Register