The February 2023 issue of IEEE Spectrum is here!

Close bar

VW Solves Quantum Chemistry Problems on a D-Wave Machine

Scientists say their work offers a proof of principle for using D-Wave’s quantum computers to tackle even tougher chemistry problems

3 min read
A photo of the D-Wave 2000Q which looks like large black boxes emblazoned with the D-Wave name in white, arranged in a room.
Photo: D-Wave

Since at least 1982, when physicist Richard Feynman first proposed the idea of quantum computers, scientists have dreamed of using such exotic machines to simulate quantum phenomena in atoms and molecules. Now, in a paper to be presented in March, scientists at Volkswagen in Munich and San Francisco have used a D-Wave 2000Q quantum computer to solve rudimentary quantum chemistry problems.

The results, the VW scientists say, offer a proof of principle of Feynman’s vision using the increasingly popular Canadian quantum computer system. The paper they will present in March, which they shared on the preprint server arXiv, describes running D-Wave computations that find the ground state energies of molecular hydrogen and the molecule lithium hydride.

Both molecules are well known and well studied. What’s new is not any breakthrough chemistry discovery but rather an increasingly promising computational route to exploring chemistry in the quantum realm. (IEEE Spectrum covered a similar effort by IBM using a different kind of quantum computer system in 2017. )

“Our goal was to get a feeling for these kinds of problems to find better methods in the future,” says Florian Neukart, principal scientist at Volkswagen Group of America in San Francisco. The researchers did not run a similar algorithm on a conventional computer system to see whether the D-Wave computation was faster.

D-Wave computers are known as “quantum annealers,” running complex circuits using the machine’s 128,000 superconducting Josephson junctions. The integrated superconducting circuit, cooled down to thousandths of a degree above absolute zero, contains 2,048 quantum bits (qubits) and 6,016 interconnections (a.k.a. couplers) between qubits. It is called an annealer because the circuit begins in one state and then slowly transitions through to its final state, with its individual qubits representing distillations of an answer.

“Not all qubits are connected [between] each other,” Neukart says of the D-Wave computer’s architecture. “For future machines, increasing the number of qubits is not the only task, increasing the connectivity (i.e. the number of couplers) is important as well.”

In a full-fledged quantum computer, a quantum phenomenon called entanglement connects every qubit with every other qubit. However, the D-Wave quantum annealer is a quantum information device that’s on the way toward a full-fledged, universal quantum computer. It is not able to run every kind of quantum algorithm that a universal quantum computer could run.

That said, Neukart says, there’s plenty that D-Wave devices can do—often involving finding optimal solutions to complex problems. To date, D-Wave computers have been used for traffic analysis, selecting investments in financial portfolios, finding promising candidates for new drug development, and studying genomics and particle physics.

Simulating quantum systems like complex molecules, Neukart says, will probably not happen until the next generation of machines is available. The D-Wave’s 2,048 qubits, while impressive compared to other (universal) devices, are still not quite ideal to run full-fledged quantum chemistry simulations.

[shortcode ieee-pullquote quote=""Our present work was a first field study of quantum chemistry problems on quantum annealing devices"" float="left" expand=1]

His group’s paper runs down a wish list of quantum chemistry simulations that sufficiently robust quantum computation should be able to tackle. Such problems include designing next-generation batteries, optimizing solar cells via detailed study of photosynthesis, and faithfully simulating complex molecules without resorting to approximations that conventional computers must rely on to make the simulations tractable.

The D-Wave can tick off none of these items on the wish list yet, he says. But larger and more interconnected quantum annealing devices may be able to approach such big problems. So the time is now, he says, to begin to understand how quantum chemistry problems run on a current generation D-Wave.

“Our present work was a first field study of quantum chemistry problems on quantum annealing devices,” he says. “Our goal was to get a feeling for the bottlenecks of the problem. This in the end helps [us] to understand the underlying problems, and find new solutions or suitable subproblems.”

Neukart says anyone looking to try their hand at their own quantum algorithms can start with D-Wave’s open-source libraries on GitHub. For beginners, he says, an actual D-Wave device isn’t even necessary. Simulations of D-Wave computations running on conventional computers are a good place to start.

“These [GitHub] libraries can be used to solve optimization problems,” Neukart says. “If access to the real chip is not available, a classical simulator can be used for first experiments. Therewith, everyone is able to learn about quantum annealing and to try it out.”

The Conversation (0)
This photo shows a man holding a silver sphere that is about the size of a bowling ball. A seated women stares at the ball. Behind her, others wait their turns.

People queue up to have their irises scanned at an outdoor sign-up event for Worldcoin in Indonesia.

WorldCoin
DarkGray

In a college classroom in the Indian city of Bangalore last August, Moiz Ahmed held up a volleyball-size chrome globe with a glass-covered opening at its center. Ahmed explained to the students that if they had their irises scanned with the device, known as the Orb, they would be rewarded with 25 Worldcoins, a soon-to-be released cryptocurrency. The scan, he said, was to make sure they hadn’t signed up before. That’s because Worldcoin, the company behind the project, wants to create the most widely and evenly distributed cryptocurrency ever by giving every person on the planet the same small allocation of coins.

Some listeners were enthusiastic, considering the meteoric rise in value that cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin since they launched. “I found it to be a very unique opportunity,” said Diksha Rustagi. “You can probably earn a lot from Worldcoin in the future.” Others were more cautious, including a woman who goes by Chaitra R, who hung at the back of the classroom as her fellow students signed up. “I have a lot of doubts,” she said. “We would like to know how it’s going to help us.”

Keep Reading ↓Show less
{"imageShortcodeIds":[]}