Verizon and AT&T Prepare to Bring 5G to Market

Controversy flares as rivals rush to launch 5G services

4 min read
Illustration graph with 5G at the top
Photo-illustration: Edmon de Haro

Illustration graph with 5G at the topPhoto-illustration: Edmon de Haro

Top Tech 2017 logo

Unlike most epochs, those of the wireless age have come and gone with convenient numerical designations. And with each came marvelous new capabilities: 2G let us all text for the first time, for example, and 3G empowered us to surf the Web.

So now, as phone makers and Internet service providers begin hashing out the details of what 5G will be and how it will work, speculation is high about what new marvels will be possible when carriers can deliver data to smartphones at rates as high as 100 megabits per second [PDF]. Soon, we’ll start to find out: This year, Verizon and AT&T plan to deliver broadband Internet to select homes or businesses using fixed wireless networks built with early 5G technologies. These 5G pilot programs will give the public its first glimpse into a wireless future that isn’t due to fully arrive until the early 2020s.

With 5G, carriers hope to deliver data to smartphone users at speeds 10 times as fast as on today’s 4G networks, and with only 1 millisecond of delay. Right now, standards groups including the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) are in the middle of an eight-year process to set technical specifications and performance parameters for 5G that should be ready around 2020. “At this time, everything is open,” says Colin Langtry, who oversees 5G for the ITU.

For many invested in the 5G rollout, that extended timetable could be a problem. By the time standards are finalized in 2020, carriers and governments will have already poured US $5 billion into 5G development. With so much cash on the line, and facing pressure from data-hungry customers, carriers are moving fast. Over the past year, companies have completed a flurry of lab tests and trials to figure out what types of radios, antennas, and signal processing techniques will work best to deliver 5G in hopes of bringing those technologies and their capabilities to market as soon as possible.

Global Cellular Access

bar chartNinety-five percent of the world’s 7.4 billion residents have access to a cellular network. Among them, quality of service varies considerably. Source: International Telecommunication Union

“5G is really an amorphous term,” says Thyaga Nandagopal, a program director for the National Science Foundation who oversees wireless initiatives. “But it’s increasingly going to become very narrowly focused on a few technologies, very fast.”

Both Verizon and AT&T say their 2017 fixed wireless networks will rely on millimeter waves, which are arguably the hottest new 5G technology. Millimeter waves are officially defined as waves transmitted at frequencies between 30 and 300 gigahertz, and they are between 1 and 10 millimeters in length. That’s much shorter than traditional cellular signals, which have frequencies below 6 GHz, typically far below, with wavelengths in the tens of centimeters.

Millimeter waves could solve a big problem for today’s carriers: Customers want to transmit more data at once, but the traditional, sub-6-GHz bands are more crowded than they’ve ever been. In contrast, millimeter waves are part of a wide-open section of spectrum, which offers intriguing possibilities.

In early tests, Verizon homed in on one band in particular—28 GHz, which has become a clear favorite for 5G after the U.S. Federal Communications Commission opened it and a handful of other high-frequency bands for commercial use in July 2016. AT&T, too, has tested millimeter waves at 28 GHz and on another popular band, 15 GHz, at its trial site in Austin, Texas. In the lab, AT&T has achieved peak data speeds of 14 gigabits per second at 15 GHz.

Other companies have also had encouraging results. Last year, Sprint demonstrated peak data speeds of 4 Gb/s—good enough to stream a virtual-reality demo for spectators—on that same 15-GHz band at the 2016 Copa América Centenario soccer tournament, in Philadelphia. In Japan, NTT Docomo has incorporated another 5G technology called MIMO (multiple-input, multiple output), in which dozens of programmable antennas are made to send and receive signals at once from a single base station, to reach a blazing 20 Gb/s at 15 GHz. At that speed, a complete 2-hour, 1080p, high-definition movie can be transmitted in a second and a half.

Now, Verizon and AT&T are eager to share with customers the speedy data rates they have seen in early tests, despite the fact that comprehensive 5G standards are still years away. But though these two companies may be the first to bring millimeter waves to customers, their fixed wireless networks will fall short of what many experts consider “true” 5G.

Unlike the networks that connect smartphones, fixed wireless systems send a focused beam to connect one stationary point to another, such as a base station to a rooftop antenna. From there, carriers run Ethernet cables from the antenna to deliver broadband Internet to offices or apartments within a building.

To fully achieve 5G, carriers and smartphone manufacturers must also figure out how to deliver high-speed data to mobile users who are riding in cars or trains or walking on sidewalks. And the grandest vision for 5G extends far beyond mobile devices—to autonomous cars, connected appliances, and industrial robots.

There are other problems, too. Millimeter waves don’t easily penetrate obstacles such as buildings, and they are more readily absorbed than traditional microwave cell signals by water and oxygen molecules in the air. So they require more power to travel the same distances as the signals from today’s smartphones. Given these issues, using millimeter waves to serve mobile users will require more sophisticated signal processing and a greater density of base stations than are available today.

Some critics think fixed wireless deployments are an unfortunate distraction at a time when companies should be focused on developing these other capabilities. “Effectively, that’s delaying mobile 5G,” says Paul Struhsaker, chief technical officer for the investment group Carnegie Technologies.

Competitors also warn that Verizon and AT&T may have to forfeit their early fixed wireless investments if other companies turn up even better technologies in time, and industry experts fret about fragmentation across carriers. “The problem with prestandard implementation has always been you risk that your investment after three years is outdated,” says Günther Ottendorfer, Sprint’s chief operating officer for technology.

Still, Sanyogita Shamsunder, Verizon’s director for network planning, says the company will press ahead with its bold 2017 plan for 5G through fixed wireless. “We see a reasonable use case that we think we can address with this technology, so we’re going to do it,” she says.

This article appears in the January 2017 print issue as “Here Comes 5G—Whatever That Is.”

Keep reading...Show less

This article is for IEEE members only. Join IEEE to access our full archive.

Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to all of Spectrum’s articles, podcasts, and special reports. Learn more →

If you're already an IEEE member, please sign in to continue reading.

Membership includes:

  • Get unlimited access to IEEE Spectrum content
  • Follow your favorite topics to create a personalized feed of IEEE Spectrum content
  • Save Spectrum articles to read later
  • Network with other technology professionals
  • Establish a professional profile
  • Create a group to share and collaborate on projects
  • Discover IEEE events and activities
  • Join and participate in discussions

Meet the Members Running for 2024 IEEE President-Elect

Roger Fujii and Kathleen Kramer are experienced leaders

2 min read
Photo of the two candidates for 2024 pres-elect
Joey Ikemoto; JT MacMillan

The IEEE Board of Directors has nominated Life Fellow Roger Fujii and Senior Member Kathleen Kramer as candidates for IEEE president-elect.

The winner of this year’s election will serve as IEEE president in 2025. For more information about the election, president-elect candidates, and petition process, visit the IEEE election website.

Keep Reading ↓Show less

Designing a Silicon Photonic MEMS Phase Shifter With Simulation

Engineers at EPFL used simulation to design photonic devices for enhanced optical network speed, capacity, and reliability

4 min read
Designing a Silicon Photonic MEMS Phase Shifter With Simulation
EPFL

This sponsored article is brought to you by COMSOL.

The modern internet-connected world is often described as wired, but most core network data traffic is actually carried by optical fiber — not electric wires. Despite this, existing infrastructure still relies on many electrical signal processing components embedded inside fiber optic networks. Replacing these components with photonic devices could boost network speed, capacity, and reliability. To help realize the potential of this emerging technology, a multinational team at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne (EPFL) has developed a prototype of a silicon photonic phase shifter, a device that could become an essential building block for the next generation of optical fiber data networks.

Keep Reading ↓Show less
{"imageShortcodeIds":["32366883","32366901","32366913"]}