The December 2022 issue of IEEE Spectrum is here!

Close bar

UK Revenue and Customs Computer Errors Whack 100,000 Taxpayers

Government Had Been Claiming IT System Was Working As It Should

1 min read
UK Revenue and Customs Computer Errors Whack 100,000 Taxpayers

In January, I blogged about complaints involving the new Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC) computer systems that combines information on National Insurance contributions and Pay As you Earn (PAYE) for the first time. At the time, several news reports were warning that many UK taxpayers would likely be paying too much tax this year for a whole host of reasons such as being placed in an incorrect tax bracket because of errors in the HMRC database.

At the time, the HMRC downplayed the complaints and warnings and "insisted the IT behind the new system is working as it should."

Well, now the HMRC is admitting that at least 100,000 taxpayers have erroneously paid too much tax because of errors in - surprise, surprise - its computer systems.

According to this story in the London Telegraph, the HMRC also says that pensioners are the hardest group hit since they have the most complicated tax codes.

The Telegraph story goes on to say that,

 "Examples of errors include people having their personal tax allowances removed, being placed on higher tax codes or even having a '1' inserted in front of their salary, erroneously inflating up their taxable income by £100,000."

In other words, problems the HMRC was warned about in January along with some new ones.

In addition, the Telegraph reports that taxpayers are having a hard time getting through to HMRC help lines, and are sometimes being cut-off before they can report their problems.

An HMRC spokesperson was quoted in the Telegraph story as saying that the HMRC apologized for the problems, and that, "Unfortunately with a project of this scale things will occasionally go wrong..."

I guess what that means is that HMRC IT systems "occasionally" going wrong implies that they are working exactly as they should.

The Conversation (0)

Why Functional Programming Should Be the Future of Software Development

It’s hard to learn, but your code will produce fewer nasty surprises

11 min read
A plate of spaghetti made from code
Shira Inbar

You’d expectthe longest and most costly phase in the lifecycle of a software product to be the initial development of the system, when all those great features are first imagined and then created. In fact, the hardest part comes later, during the maintenance phase. That’s when programmers pay the price for the shortcuts they took during development.

So why did they take shortcuts? Maybe they didn’t realize that they were cutting any corners. Only when their code was deployed and exercised by a lot of users did its hidden flaws come to light. And maybe the developers were rushed. Time-to-market pressures would almost guarantee that their software will contain more bugs than it would otherwise.

Keep Reading ↓Show less