The December 2022 issue of IEEE Spectrum is here!

Close bar

When AI “Played” Math, It Cracked an Internet Chokepoint

A mod of DeepMind’s game engine finds a shortcut for an algorithm unimproved on since the punch-card era

4 min read
When AI “Played” Math, It Cracked an Internet Chokepoint

An artificial intelligence system from Google’s sibling company DeepMind stumbled on a new way to solve a foundational math problem at the heart of modern computing, a new study finds. A modification of the company’s game engine AlphaZero (famously used to defeat chess grandmasters and legends in the game of Go) outperformed an algorithm that had not been improved on for more than 50 years, researchers say.

The new research focused on multiplying grids of numbers known as matrices. Matrix multiplication is an operation key to many computational tasks, such as processing images, recognizing speech commands, training neural networks, running simulations to predict the weather, and compressing data for sharing on the Internet.

“Finding new matrix-multiplication algorithms could help speed up many of these applications,” says study lead author Alhussein Fawzi, a research scientist at London-based DeepMind, a subsidiary of Google’s parent company Alphabet.

“AlphaTensor provides an important proof of concept that with machine learning, we can go beyond existing state-of-the-art algorithms, and therefore that machine learning will play a fundamental role in the field of algorithmic discovery.”
—Alhussein Fawzi, DeepMind

The standard technique for multiplying two matrices together is usually to multiply the rows of one with the columns of the other. However, in 1969, the German mathematician Volker Strassen surprised the math world by discovering a more efficient method. When it comes to multiplying a pair of two-by-two matrices—ones that each have two rows and two columns—the standard algorithm takes eight steps. In contrast, Strassen’s takes only seven.

However, decades of research after Strassen’s breakthrough, larger versions of this problem are still unsolved. For example, it remains unknown how efficiently one can multiply a pair of matrices as small as three by three, Fawzi says.

series of letters and numbers showcasing algorithmsHere, we show the standard algorithm compared with Strassen’s algorithm, which uses one less scalar multiplication (seven instead of eight) for multiplying two-by-two matrices. Multiplications matter much more than additions for overall efficiency.DeepMind

“I felt from the very beginning that machine learning could help a lot in this field, by finding the best patterns—that is, which entries to combine in the matrices and how to combine them—to get the right result,” Fawzi says.

In the new study, Fawzi and his colleagues explored how AI might help automatically discover new matrix-multiplication algorithms. They built on Strassen’s research, which focused on ways to break down 3D arrays of numbers called matrix-multiplication tensors into their elementary components.

The scientists developed an AI system dubbed AlphaTensor based on AlphaZero, which they earlier developed to master chess, Go, and other games. They converted the problem of breaking down tensors into a single-player game and trained AlphaTensor to find efficient ways to win the game.

The researchers noted that this game proved extraordinarily challenging. The number of possible algorithms that AlphaTensor has to consider is much greater than the number of atoms in the universe, even for small cases of matrix multiplication. In one scenario, there were more than 1033 possible moves at each step of the game.

“The search space was gigantic,” Fawzi says.

“In the next few years, many new algorithms for fundamental computational tasks that we use every day will be discovered with the help of machine learning.”
—Alhussein Fawzi, DeepMind

When AlphaTensor began, it had no knowledge about existing algorithms for matrix multiplication. By playing the game repeatedly and learning from the outcomes, it gradually improved.

“AlphaTensor is the first AI system for discovering novel, efficient, and provably correct algorithms for fundamental tasks such as matrix multiplication,” Fawzi says.

AlphaTensor eventually discovered up to thousands of matrix-multiplication algorithms for each size of matrix it examined, revealing that the realm of matrix-multiplication algorithms was richer than previously thought. These included algorithms faster than any previously known. For example, AlphaTensor discovered an algorithm for multiplying four-by-four matrices in just 47 steps, improving on Strassen’s 50-year-old algorithm, which uses 49.

“The first time we saw that we were able to improve over existing known algorithms was very exciting,” Fawzi recalls.

These new algorithms possess a variety of different mathematical properties with a range of potential applications. The scientists modified AlphaTensor to find algorithms that are fast on a given hardware device, such as Nvidia V100 GPU and Google TPU v2. They discovered algorithms that multiply large matrices 10 to 20 percent faster than the commonly used algorithms on the same hardware.

“AlphaTensor provides an important proof of concept that with machine learning, we can go beyond existing state-of-the-art algorithms, and therefore that machine learning will play a fundamental role in the field of algorithmic discovery going forward,” Fawzi says. “I believe that in the next few years, many new algorithms for fundamental computational tasks that we use every day will be discovered with the help of machine learning.”

AlphaTensor started with no knowledge about the problem it tackled. This suggests that an interesting future direction might be to combine it with approaches that embed mathematical knowledge about the problem, “which will potentially allow the system to scale further,” Fawzi says.

In addition, “we are also looking to apply AlphaTensor to other fundamental operations used in computer science,” Fawzi says. “Many problems in computer science and math have similarities to the way we framed the problem in our research, so we believe that our paper will spur new results in mathematics and computer science with the help of machine learning.”

The scientists detailed their findings on 5 October in the journal Nature.

The Conversation (1)
Richard Brent14 Nov, 2022

It should be noted that the new 47-step algorithm does not work over the field of real numbers. It only works over fields with characteristic 2. Thus, for most scientific/engineering applications, there is no improvement.

Richard Brent FIEEE

Will AI Steal Submarines’ Stealth?

Better detection will make the oceans transparent—and perhaps doom mutually assured destruction

11 min read
A photo of a submarine in the water under a partly cloudy sky.

The Virginia-class fast attack submarine USS Virginia cruises through the Mediterranean in 2010. Back then, it could effectively disappear just by diving.

U.S. Navy

Submarines are valued primarily for their ability to hide. The assurance that submarines would likely survive the first missile strike in a nuclear war and thus be able to respond by launching missiles in a second strike is key to the strategy of deterrence known as mutually assured destruction. Any new technology that might render the oceans effectively transparent, making it trivial to spot lurking submarines, could thus undermine the peace of the world. For nearly a century, naval engineers have striven to develop ever-faster, ever-quieter submarines. But they have worked just as hard at advancing a wide array of radar, sonar, and other technologies designed to detect, target, and eliminate enemy submarines.

The balance seemed to turn with the emergence of nuclear-powered submarines in the early 1960s. In a 2015 study for the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessment, Bryan Clark, a naval specialist now at the Hudson Institute, noted that the ability of these boats to remain submerged for long periods of time made them “nearly impossible to find with radar and active sonar.” But even these stealthy submarines produce subtle, very-low-frequency noises that can be picked up from far away by networks of acoustic hydrophone arrays mounted to the seafloor.

Keep Reading ↓Show less