The June 2024 issue of IEEE Spectrum is here!

Close bar

Loser: Satellite TV Soccer Moms Will Hate

Sirius’s car TV may be great technology, but it will drive parents crazy

5 min read
Loser: Satellite TV Soccer Moms Will Hate

Now Showing: Sirius Backseat TV rebroadcasts programming from cartoon Network, the Disney channel, and Nickelodeon.

Photo: Chrysler

The problem with boffo product demos is that people might take you seriously. And they might do it long before you’re sure it’s a product people need or want.

As a case in point, consider Sirius Satellite Radio’s Backseat TV, introduced this past fall. Sirius, based in New York City, first demonstrated satellite TV for cars at the January 2003 Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas. It wasn’t meant to be a real product, just a conceptual demo. Terry Smith, senior vice president of engineering for Sirius, says, “We were just flexing our muscles a bit. We put it on as a technology demonstration, just to prove that bits are bits and Sirius could be an entertainment company, not just a radio company.”

Then some of the auto­motive companies already installing Sirius Radio hardware as optional equipment saw the demos and pushed the company to get the product into production.

On the face of it, adding video to audio offerings doesn’t seem like a bad idea. Today, 29 percent of the 115 million households in the United States subscribe to satellite TV, according to the Consumer Electronics Association, in Arlington, Va. That’s a tempting market.

Turning a technology demonstration into a commercial product isn’t always easy. In this case, the first hurdle was to develop a new modulation scheme. For the demo, Sirius had temporarily taken several radio channels off the air and given the TV broadcast all the bandwidth it needed. But a commercial product would have to fit into the Sirius network without cannibalizing the radio channels quite so gluttonously, and without making it impossible for existing satellite radio units to continue to receive the company’s audio programming.

The engineers of Sirius’s Advanced Development Team in Lawrenceville, N.J., got to work. Enthusiastic about the product, the company announced in January 2005 that it would launch Sirius TV in 2006. That didn’t happen. “The PR got out in front of our technology a little bit,” Smith says.

But the engineers really rose to the occasion. They developed an impressive new transmission technology that breaks up the video signal and combines chunks of it with each of the more than 130 radio channels that fill Sirius’s allocated 12.5 megahertz of spectrum. Existing radio receivers screen out that signal as noise, but the new TV receivers recognize the signal as data and decode it.

This is an implementation of a transmission technique called hierarchical modulation, in which two streams of data are sent at a given frequency; one is given a high ­priority—in this case, the radio ­programming—the other, the pieces of video data, are assigned a lower priority. Sirius’s new signal carries enough data for three TV channels at a resolution that looks fine on an 8-inch-diagonal screen. (Sirius won’t say what the exact resolution is.) And it has some bandwidth left over for additional applications that have yet to be determined but may include data services.

To squeeze the video into a package small enough to be transmitted on top of the radio channels without affecting their reception, Sirius engineers chose the H.264 standard for video compression but tweaked it—exactly how they changed it is proprietary. H.264 was the obvious choice. It’s part of the MPEG-4 suite of standards, it’s in blue-laser DVD systems, and it’s used in Norway for digital TV broadcasts. A host of other countries are including the standard in their digital broadcast plans.

The engineers also beefed up Sirius’s existing error-correction software to reduce dropouts and designed the system to use two antennas—one attached to the front of the vehicle and the other to the rear—to improve the system’s chances of picking up the satellite signal. The team also developed a chip that implements this technology, which is being fabricated by STMicroelectronics, headquartered in Geneva. The Delphi Electronics and Safety Division of Delphi Corp., in Troy, Mich., designed and manufactures the receiver hardware.

Sirius signed agreements to rebroadcast the programming of three child-oriented TV channels—Cartoon Network, Disney Channel, and Nickelodeon. The service, now called Backseat TV, launched late last year. It debuts in 2008 Chrysler Town & Country and Dodge Grand Caravan minivans (with more car models in the pipeline) and is sold through electronics retailers as an aftermarket add-on. A Backseat TV add-on to Chrysler’s rear-seat entertainment system costs US $470; the whole package, including two DVD players, two 8-inch video screens, a rear backup camera, and a one-year subscription to Sirius Radio and TV, costs $2020 for high-end models of the minivans (in which some features are already standard), more for less expensive models. In retail stores, a Sirius Backseat TV receiver, without a subscription, lists at $300. The subscription price is $7 per month, added to the $12.95 Sirius Radio subscription; you can’t get a Backseat TV subscription by itself.

What the Experts Say“Low-bandwidth satellite-video-subscription services with a small demographic, few channels, and high initial cost seem doomed to failure. On the bright side, adding video to satellite radio will permit measurement of whether losses escalate linearly or are a function of broadcast bandwidth.”—Nick Tredennicke

The engineers at Sirius are delighted to see their muscle flexing become a real product. “To be able to provide a whole new range of service on top of an already deployed consumer electronics product is really cool,” Sirius’s Smith says. “If you look at the amount of technology we developed, what it took to get that technology into silicon, and all the quality gates that the automotive industry requires you go through, I think we’ve turned this around in an impressive time.”

The initial customer response seems positive, if mildly so. Mike Kane, Chrysler’s director of advanced technology strategy, says that 20 percent of the Town & Country minivans now rolling off the assembly line have Backseat TV installed; for comparison, about 35 percent of buyers have purchased the DVD-only entertainment system in the past. But for soccer moms, the product’s main audience, Backseat TV ain’t the only game in town. And Backseat TV doesn’t appear to be the game soccer moms want to play. In fact, some seem downright hostile.

“If it were free and came standard, I’d pay to have it taken out!” huffs Catherine McNiel, a mom in Glendale Heights, Ill. Adds Alma Klein, a mother and advertising executive in Oak Park, Ill.: “I can only imagine how annoying it would be to pull into the supermarket parking lot only to hear, ‘No, don’t turn the car off, my program’s still on!’ ” [Click here for more comments .]

Industry observers acknowledge that with so many ways to get video in the car—portable game consoles, iPods, laptops, and some cellphones, in addition to DVDs—consumers are not going to be clamoring for this product.

Says James McQuivey, an analyst with Forrester Research, Cambridge, Mass.: “The future of video in the automobile is on-demand; it isn’t broadcast. Broadcast may be a temporary blip, but eventually you will have what you want to watch in your car when you want to watch it, whether it comes by shiny disk or iPod or wireless connection. You won’t be watching whatever someone is willing to broadcast to you.”

Thilo Koslowski, lead automotive analyst and a vice president with Stamford, Conn.–based Gartner, does not see Backseat TV as a compelling product in a world with many on-demand video options. But Koslowski commends Sirius for innovating, because innovation in satellite radio has been a pretty rare commodity for a while.

He says, it would have been a really bad idea for the company to pull the plug on the project after talking about it for so long. And Sirius did prove that, indeed, even far-out demos can come true.

Sirius Backseat TV

Loser: Consumer

Goal: To provide three channels of broadcast TV to children traveling in the backseats of automobiles.

Why It’s a Loser: DVD players and hard disk ­recorders like TiVo have given parents unprecedented control of their children’s entertainment options; the last thing they want is to give up that control in the car.

Player: Sirius Satellite Radio’s Advanced Development Team

Where: Lawrenceville, N.J.

Staff: 15 to 20

Budget: Info not available



This article is for IEEE members only. Join IEEE to access our full archive.

Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to all of Spectrum’s articles, podcasts, and special reports. Learn more →

If you're already an IEEE member, please sign in to continue reading.

Membership includes:

  • Get unlimited access to IEEE Spectrum content
  • Follow your favorite topics to create a personalized feed of IEEE Spectrum content
  • Save Spectrum articles to read later
  • Network with other technology professionals
  • Establish a professional profile
  • Create a group to share and collaborate on projects
  • Discover IEEE events and activities
  • Join and participate in discussions