Why Boston Dynamics Is Putting Legged Robots in Hospitals

Boston Dynamics explains why robots with legs are worth it, even in triage tents

5 min read
Boston Dynamics' Spot robot can be used in COVID triage tents
Photo: MIT/Brigham and Women’s Hospital/Boston Dynamics

For the past eight months, Boston Dynamics has been trying to find ways in which their friendly yellow quadruped, Spot, can provide some kind of useful response to COVID-19. The company has been working with researchers from MIT and Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Massachusetts to use Spot as a telepresence-based extension for healthcare workers in suitable contexts, with the goal of minimizing exposure and preserving supplies of PPE.

For triaging sick patients, it’s necessary to collect a variety of vital data, including body temperature, respiration rate, pulse rate, and oxygen saturation. Boston Dynamics has helped to develop “a set of contactless  monitoring systems for measuring vital signs and a tablet computer to enable face-to-face medical interviewing,” all of which fits neatly on Spot’s back. This system was recently tested in a medical tent for COVID-19 triage, which appeared to be a well constrained and very flat environment that left us wondering whether a legged platform like Spot was really necessary in this particular application. What makes Spot unique (and relatively complex and expensive) is its ability to navigate around complex environments in an agile manner. But in a tent in a hospital parking lot, are you really getting your US $75k worth out of those legs, or would a wheeled platform do almost as well while being significantly simpler and more affordable?

As it turns out, we weren’t the only ones who wondered whether Spot is really the best platform for this application. “We had the same response when we started getting pitched these opportunities in Feb / March,” Michael Perry, Boston Dynamics’ VP of business development commented on Twitter. “As triage tents started popping up in late March, though, there wasn’t confidence wheeled robots would be able to handle arbitrary triage environments (parking lots, lawns, etc).”

To better understand Spot’s value in this role, we sent Boston Dynamics a few questions about their approach to healthcare robots.

This video shows Dr. Spot (their nickname, not ours) walking around Brigham and Women’s Hospital.

While the video is very focused on Spot itself, the researchers also released a  paper about the effectiveness of Spot’s payload, and about how well it worked in the triage tent, which was outside of the hospital and looks like this:

Boston Dynamics' Spot at triage areaThe COVID-19 triage area at Brigham and Women’s Hospital includes a medical tent outside of the emergency department (a), where the researchers deployed a Spot with IR camera for fever screening and respiratory rate detection (b).Photo: MIT/Brigham and Women’s Hospital/Boston Dynamics

To me, this seems like somewhere a wheeled robot would do just fine, although Boston Dynamics told us that the tent also had “concrete bumps and curbs that made mobility a challenge.” Spot left the tent and wandered around the hospital when the small number of hospital staff that had been trained to operate the robot rotated to the emergency department instead. It turns out that there’s a second, separate paper in the works about the effectiveness of Spot for telemedicine that’s still under peer review, but it’ll more directly address how useful Spot itself is as a platform in a busy hospital. 

But back to our question of how useful a legged robot like Spot is in a well-constrained and mostly flat environment like the triage tent—concrete bumps and curbs could certainly be a challenge, but it seems like minor alterations to the environment (say, adding some ramps or something) would be much more cost effective than picking a legged robot over a wheeled robot. Even if there are obstacles (like stairs) that are difficult for a wheeled robot, using two (or more?) wheeled robots instead of one legged robot could still potentially be a more efficient solution.

Spot robot dogThe researchers mounted four cameras on Spot and showed that they can measure skin temperature, breathing rate, pulse rate, and blood oxygen saturation in healthy patients, from a distance of 2 meters.Photo: MIT/Brigham and Women’s Hospital/Boston Dynamics

For that matter, why use a robot when you could just make your remote monitoring system stationary, instead? That was our first question for Boston Dynamics roboticist Marco da Silva and field applications lead Seth Davis.

IEEE Spectrum: From what I understand from the paper, the goal was to develop a system that can adapt its distance and angle of view to take more accurate readings of patients, rather than asking patients to adapt to a static system. Why make this a mobile robot at all, rather than (for example) something that sits on a table with a couple of actuated DoFs that make the necessary adjustments?

Marco da Silva: It’s possible that you could build an actuated device expressly for this purpose but Spot already existed and was ready to be deployed. Further, the Brigham and Women’s team was expecting long lines of patients at intake or patients seated in the tent. The expectation was that Spot could efficiently move from patient to patient.

Your Boston Dynamics colleague Michael Perry mentioned that “there wasn’t confidence wheeled robots would be able to handle arbitrary triage environments (parking lots, lawns, etc.).” Can you elaborate on that?

Seth Davis: We initially questioned the need for legged robots or even a mobile platform. In this case, the Brigham and Women’s and MIT teams informed us that a wheeled robot with sufficient payload capacity was not readily available and not well suited to the initial concept which was to operate outside the hospital in temporary treatment areas. In addition to its mobility, our robots’ obstacle avoidance abilities and simple user interface also seemed appealing to the Brigham and Women’s team as they worked right out of the box and did not require additional development or significant training in order to get something their staff could use. 

“In addition to its mobility, our robots’ obstacle avoidance abilities and simple user interface also seemed appealing to the Brigham and Women’s team as they worked right out of the box and did not require additional development or significant training in order to get something their staff could use.”

With the experience that you have now, do you think that legged robots are worth the extra cost and complexity in these situations, relative to a (likely much less expensive) wheeled platform?

Davis: It depends on the environment, the requirements for speed of deployment, and how flexible the solution needs to be. It’s highly likely that the pandemic is going to have researchers looking at creating one robotic solution (fixed or mobile) to interact with patients. In this instance, the rapidly evolving pandemic situation necessitated a robot that could be deployed in a tent, a parking lot, a lawn, or in the Emergency Department, and rapidly adapt to the sensor and data collection needs of their team. 

Has this experience suggested any other healthcare applications where legged robots would be uniquely useful?

Da Silva: We have a few hospitals around the world that are interested in this specific configuration of Spot as a “just in case” solution if or when their triage facilities need to be set up in an unknown environment. Moving forward we have teams that are looking at delivering goods and doing rounds in convalescent facilities, and mobile disinfection in ad hoc or unstructured environments. One thing we learned as well is that elevator usage is often over capacity in hospitals causing long wait times, so we’ve been approached to see how Spot can carry physical items up and down the stairs to alleviate elevator congestion.

The Conversation (0)

How Robots Can Help Us Act and Feel Younger

Toyota’s Gill Pratt on enhancing independence in old age

10 min read
An illustration of a woman making a salad with robotic arms around her holding vegetables and other salad ingredients.
Dan Page
Blue

By 2050, the global population aged 65 or more will be nearly double what it is today. The number of people over the age of 80 will triple, approaching half a billion. Supporting an aging population is a worldwide concern, but this demographic shift is especially pronounced in Japan, where more than a third of Japanese will be 65 or older by midcentury.

Toyota Research Institute (TRI), which was established by Toyota Motor Corp. in 2015 to explore autonomous cars, robotics, and “human amplification technologies,” has also been focusing a significant portion of its research on ways to help older people maintain their health, happiness, and independence as long as possible. While an important goal in itself, improving self-sufficiency for the elderly also reduces the amount of support they need from society more broadly. And without technological help, sustaining this population in an effective and dignified manner will grow increasingly difficult—first in Japan, but globally soon after.

Keep Reading ↓Show less