We learned last week that Honda is putting Asimo out to pasture, so to speak, which is a little sad, but not too sad: Honda is doing this because they want to instead focus on the other, more useful humanoid robots that they’ve been working on recently, like E2-DR. Honda learned a lot about humanoid robotics from Asimo, and even though we haven’t seen Asimo do much in the way of new stuff over the past few years, the robot has still been under active development. Or at least, it was, as of 2017, when Honda was teaching it to handle human abuse.
Nobody likes to see robots getting pushed or kicked, but we can make exceptions when roboticists are doing it for research-related reasons—for example, to demonstrate how resilient their quadrupeds or humanoids are by trying to shove them over. Boston Dynamics is famous for this, but Atlas is not the only humanoid talented enough to (mostly) keep itself upright in response to aggressive prodding.
At the IEEE International Conference on Humanoid Robots last year, Honda Research presented a rare look inside Asimo, both literally and figuratively. They’ve been working on teaching Asimo creative ways of handling shoves, by making dynamic transitions from standing or walking to hopping or jogging when necessary to keep its balance, and they did it with an Asimo that had almost no body covering.
Well, I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Asimo with exposed leg hardware before, so that’s cool.
What you’re watching in the video is Asimo recovering from two shoves: one in the forward direction, and one in the lateral direction. Shove recovery for humanoids in general (two-legged humans included) is accomplished by keeping your center of gravity within the area that your feet are able to support. To recover from a forward or backward shove, most people (and humanoid robots) take a step or a series of steps proportional to how hard the shove was—a stronger shove requires a bigger step or more smaller steps to keep torso mostly above leg and foot. However, if the shove is too strong, the necessary step length becomes larger than you (or the robot) can manage, or it simply happens too fast to react. For robots, this usually means a face-plant.
Honda’s new strategy with Asimo is to take longer and faster steps to recover from bigger shoves by transitioning to a running gait, which is exactly what humans do if we need to. Asimo uses a new kind of motion planner that can dynamically select different gaits in order to choose the most effective way to keep from falling over. The hopping comes in when Asimo is shoved laterally in the direction while it’s walking—in this case, the robot can’t move the leg that it’s using to support itself, and that leg is also blocking the other leg (the swing leg) from being used, which requires the hopping motion.
The video shows everything working flawlessly, as videos attached to papers usually do, but the researchers are perfectly honest about how well this actually works, noting that “the robot fell over many times in the same kind of experiments.” In particular, they need to speed up gait planning, and also improve the robot’s hopping motion to make things robust. Just like with humans, though, there’s a finite magnitude of shove that we can physically handle without falling over, and our last-ditch tactic to prevent ground contact is to catch ourselves with our arms. The Honda researchers would like to implement a similar behavior in their humanoids by transitioning from bipedal to quadrupedal locomotion:
Additionally, one of the ideas is adding the transition to quadrupedal to the candidate of the locomotion mode selection. We consider that the motion to make the transition to quadrupedal is the ultimate motion to compensate for large disturbances, because a human also touches the ground if extremely disturbed.
We saw this bipedal to quadrupedal transition with Honda’s E2-DR disaster robot, so it seems likely that Honda may already have integrated Asimo’s shove recovery into their other humanoids as well. Even if we don’t see anything new from Asimo going forward, we’ll be able to look at behaviors like these in Honda’s future robots, and remember where they came from. Asimo, you had a good run.
“Dynamic Gait Transition between Walking, Running and Hopping for Push Recovery,” by Takumi Kamioka, Hiroyuki Kaneko, Mitsuhide Kuroda, Chiaki Tanaka, Shinya Shirokura, Masanori Takeda, and Takahide Yoshiike from Honda Research Japan, was presented at Humanoids 2017.
Evan Ackerman is a senior editor at IEEE Spectrum. Since 2007, he has written over 6,000 articles on robotics and technology. He has a degree in Martian geology and is excellent at playing bagpipes.