"Beachfront
Spectrum" is what analysts are calling that
soon-to-be-auctioned upper 108 MHz, because it is ideal
for cellular services. Signals at those frequencies
propagate farther and penetrate buildings better than
signals in today's cellular bands, which go up to 1.9
gigahertz. Best of all, cellphone system operators
expect infrastructure costs to be reduced by 90 percent,
because fewer cells will be required, given the longer
distances signals will travel.
Thanks to such advantages, the cellular phone
companies are likely to compete hard for this valuable
bandwidth. Exactly what they would do with it is a
closely guarded secret, at least until winning bidders
are selected. Nevertheless, it's not hard to imagine the
winners launching third-generation services, including
mobile video and wide-band Internet access, which would
enable cellphone users to receive video programming and
e-mail on the run.
The FCC's huge menu of allowable uses for the new
frequencies identifies "[f]lexible fixed, mobile, and
broadcast uses, including mobile and other digital new
broadcast operations; fixed and mobile wireless
commercial services, as well as fixed and mobile
wireless uses for private, internal radio needs. Could
also include two-way interactive, cellular, and mobile
television broadcasting services."
Perhaps the best early
indicators of what will happen with the
freed-up bandwidth are recent events in Berlin—the
first city to turn off analog television—and in the
United States, where a couple of preemptive auctions
gave developers access to segments of spectrum on the
condition that they not interfere with broadcasters
still using them.
The "Berlin Switch" is an intriguing novelty. It was
possible because the region affected is relatively
small, with 1.8 million households in the TV market, and
because an overwhelming number of those households—all
but 160 000—subscribe to cable or satellite television.
Nonsubscribers each coughed up at least $200 to buy a
set-top converter, and for less than $1 million, the
government subsidized the purchase for families on
welfare.
What the switch gave Berliners, mainly, was an
increase in the number of broadcast stations—from 12 to
27. Multiplexing allows four digital channels to fit in
the space previously allotted to a single analog
channel. (This excludes HD broadcasts, because they
require more bandwidth.) The switch also gave the
government 35 MHz to use—or sell—for new services.
With more channels, viewers of broadcast television
in Berlin have access to niche programming and channels
previously available only to cable or satellite
subscribers. Programming now includes Eurosport; Arte,
with art movies, documentaries, poetry, and theater;
Phoenix, with political news; Viva II, with pop culture
for people in their 20s; and several new local channels.
In the United States, in 2001 and 2002, the FCC
auctioned off four small slices of spectrum totaling 6
MHz in the 746- to 806-MHz range, the upper 700-MHz
band, that had been allocated as "guard bands." Along
with the right to use the spectrum came tight rules to
minimize interference with public-safety services. This
RF real estate is intended for the rental market: the
buyers will act as landlords, leasing the spectrum to
third parties. The FCC packaged the spectrum in two
pieces for 52 market areas, creating 104 licenses, which
were auctioned for $540 million. The top three winners
were Access Spectrum, Nextel, and Pegasus
Communications.
Access Spectrum LLC, in Bethesda, Md., winner of 21
licenses, announced at the time that it had begun
negotiating rental agreements. In addition, Access,
formed in 2000, is likely to build private wireless
networks for businesses in some of its bands.
Plans of the other winners are murkier. Nextel is
using its 40 licenses as bargaining chips and recently
agreed to return them to the FCC as part of a deal
involving interference reduction in the 800-MHz band.
Pegasus won 34 of the 104 licenses but has been quiet
about its plans. The largest independent provider of the
DirecTV satellite service, Pegasus is having financial
problems, and some of its subsidiaries filed Chapter 11
bankruptcies in 2004.
Then, in 2002 and 2003, the FCC auctioned off 18 MHz
between 698 and 746 MHz, which covers three UHF
channels, 54, 55, and 59. Again the spectrum was
packaged into geographical pieces, both to be attractive
to buyers and to maximize returns. Channel 55 was sold
in six regional chunks, while 54 and 59 were sold as a
pair in 734 markets. Altogether the sales brought the
U.S. government $145 million.
Qualcomm Inc., of San Diego, won the auction for the
spectrum previously occupied by channel 55 in five of
the six auctions. It then bought the rights for the
sixth region from Aloha Partners LP, of Providence, R.I.
Aloha was formed to provide wireless broadband service
and has been a big player in the auctions so far.
Qualcomm intends to use its spectrum to send video
and audio programming to cellphones, PDAs, and other
portable devices nationwide. It hasn't announced what it
intends to broadcast, but the content could include hit
TV shows, clips of sporting events, and movie trailers.
The company calls its service MediaFLO ("Media" plus
"Forward Link Only"). Qualcomm plans to store video in
the handsets to supplement video streamed live; that
way, it hopes to eliminate the dropouts endemic to
cellphone reception. If a voice signal drops out
temporarily, you can just say, "What?" Video signal
dropouts, however, cause annoying freezes, jerks, or
blanks in the picture, and would discourage users.
Qualcomm is developing MediaFLO as a way to promote
CDMA cellphone technology, which it pioneered. CDMA is
winning out over the TDMA standard (popular in the
United States) and is emerging as a strong competitor to
GSM (popular in Europe). Today, CDMA is used in 35
countries, including the United States and South Korea.
Qualcomm plans to integrate MediaFLO into its chip sets
and to offer the service through partnerships with
cellphone operators. It may eventually spin it off as a
separate company.
Technology alternatives to MediaFLO are available and
could be used for competing services in spectrum bands
yet to be auctioned. One example is a variant of the
Digital Video Broadcasting standard widely adopted in
Australia, Europe, India, and elsewhere. The variant,
called DVB-H, provides TV broadcasts to handheld devices
and, like MediaFLO, is being used in the 700-MHz band.
In South Korea, yet another standard for TV broadcasting
to handhelds is being deployed—Terrestrial Digital
Multimedia Broadcasting, or T-DMB—and it may emerge as
a competitor in the United States.