ILLUSTRATION: Matt Mahurin
|
Imagine a crushing
sadness so severe it keeps you from
eating, sleeping, or socializing. Though you can't
sleep, you lack the energy and the will to get out of
bed. Everyday decisions, like which clothes to wear,
leave you paralyzed. You've no desire to do the things
you once thought were fun; in fact, you can't bring
yourself to do much of anything. Now, add to all that
the realization that you've tried everything known to
medicine, it hasn't worked, and there's a good chance
you won't feel any different. Ever.
"I had nothing to lose," says Karmen McGuffee, who
suffered from severe depression for a decade and was
hospitalized five times for it. So she had surgeons cut
open her neck, gently wrap an electrode around one of
the nerves there, and plug the electrode into a pulse
generator, which they slipped under the skin of her
chest. About every 5 minutes, the pocket-watch-size
device sends a buzz of current through the nerve and
into her brain.
Six months after doctors switched on the pulse
generator, called a vagus nerve stimulator, McGuffee's
world looked totally different. "I had no idea that life
didn't have to have a dark veil over it all the time,"
she says. Once unable to concentrate enough to read a
newspaper, McGuffee is now an executive secretary.
Depression is distressingly common, affecting more
than 120 million people around the world and sucking
tens of billions of dollars out of the global economy
through the cost of care and lost productivity. It's
also deadly. Every year 850 000 people worldwide take
their own lives, and 9 out of 10 of them are suffering
from depression, another mental illness, or substance
abuse. Statistics show that of those who had had
treatment for depression just through visits to a
doctor's office, 2 percent ultimately committed suicide,
as did 4 percent of those who had to be hospitalized for
depression.
Twenty-five percent of people with depression have no
access to any form of mental health care; of those who
do have access to care, only a quarter seek treatment.
Of those who consult doctors, some 80 percent find
relief in the form of drugs or some kind of talk
therapy, such as cognitive therapy. But for the
rest—people like McGuffee, prone to the most severe and
chronic forms of depression, about 11 million of them in
the developed world alone—drugs don't work.
For decades, the only other option for these people
was electroconvulsive therapy, which because of the
frightening side effect of amnesia is often rejected by
patients. But this grim outlook is at last beginning to
change. McGuffee was one of the first to benefit from a
new crop of electromagnetic brain stimulation
technologies that psychiatrists are testing, with the
hope of curing—or at least helping—patients for whom
little else works. By electrically manipulating specific
portions of the brain with implanted electrodes,
electric current, or magnetic fields, doctors aim to
succeed where drugs fail, by producing long-lasting
changes in the brain—and to do it without
electroshock's significant side effects.
For a variety of reasons, including the large number
of potential patients and the accumulated knowledge of
how the disease works, depression is the primary target
of most of these technologies. But some of these methods
are already showing great promise for treating such
other mental maladies as bipolar disorder,
obsessive-compulsive disorder, and bulimia.
The technology McGuffee uses, vagus nerve
stimulation, was the first to enter routine clinical
use. A pacemakerlike device about the size of a pocket
watch, implanted under the skin of the chest, pulses a
nerve in the neck [see illustration, "Vagus Nerve
Stimulation"]. In about 16 percent of
patients like McGuffee, according to clinical studies,
that electric pulsing completely quashes the symptoms of
depression. It was approved as a depression therapy, for
use in conjunction with drugs, by government regulators
in the European Union and Canada in 2001. Last June, it
became the first psychiatric device to be reviewed and
approved in the United States, which has more stringent
requirements for medical devices. Nevertheless, a number
of psychiatrists remain unconvinced that the therapy
works in enough people to outweigh the risk and cost of
surgery.
Vagus nerve stimulation isn't the only technology
being touted for treatment of the severely depressed.
Another technique, repetitive transcranial magnetic
stimulation, uses powerful magnets to generate current
in well-defined portions of the brain [see illustration,
"Repetitive Transcranial
Magnetic Stimulation"]. Many research
groups around the world have experimented with the
technology. At last count the results of more than 60
depression trials performed in Australia, Israel,
Taiwan, the United States, Europe, and elsewhere had
been published. But clinical use is just beginning. The
technology is winding its way toward a review by U.S.
regulators, and the company behind it, Neuronetics Inc.,
in Malvern, Pa., says it could be approved within the
year.
And these two are just the ones closest to the
clinic. Researchers are exploring three other, more
experimental technologies. One uses direct current to
produce a change in the brain similar to that of
magnetic stimulation. Another uses transcranial magnetic
stimulators to spark seizures just as electroconvulsive
therapy does but, it is hoped, without the amnesia that
can accompany it. The third experimental technology
borrows a device used to control the tremors of
Parkinson's disease. Surgeons have begun implanting
electrodes in patients' brains to switch off
malfunctioning brain circuits involved in depression and
obsessive-compulsive disorder.
The coming clutch of medical devices, if proven to
work, could represent not just hope for the hopeless but
a profound change in psychiatry. "I think it's not too
big a jump to say we haven't had a new [nondrug]
treatment for 40 years," says Paul Fitzgerald, an
associate professor of psychiatry at Monash University,
and deputy director of the Alfred Psychiatry Research
Center, both in Melbourne, Australia. Fitzgerald, who
does transcranial magnetic stimulation research, notes
that even the drug therapies are largely derivative of
each other. "Now we're really faced with the potential
for a significant expansion of treatments, as long as
they are introduced carefully," he adds. Noting
psychiatry's often disastrous history of nondrug
treatments, such as the embrace of prefrontal lobotomy
in the mid-20th century, he thinks the field is
approaching a watershed, for the better. "We're getting
it right this time."