A Marelli team led by Fernando Damasceno, a specialist
in ethanol-powered engines, realized they could exploit
that same feedback loop to determine, indirectly, the
ethanol percentage in the fuel mix. Here’s how: let’s
say you are running on pure gasoline. If you hit the gas
pedal and add air to the fuel mix going into the
cylinders, the ECU easily calculates the amount of fuel
needed to keep things “happy,” that is, to reach the
stoichiometric ratio. Now suppose there’s some ethanol,
in addition to gasoline, in the tank. The ethanol—whose
energy density is less than gasoline’s—reduces the
stoichiometric air-to-fuel ratio of the mixture, and
that means you need more fuel in proportion to air to
burn both completely.
But if the ECU doesn’t know how much ethanol is in the
tank, how does it know what the new stoichiometric ratio
is? It doesn’t, initially. The ECU keeps increasing the
amount of fuel injected while it monitors the oxygen
probe at the exhaust. It knows when the stoichiometric
ratio has been reached when it determines there is no
oxygen there. The ECU records the fuel increment and
compares it to values stored in its memory, and in that
way it finds that the mixture is, say, 90 percent
gasoline and 10 percent ethanol. Each time fuel is added
to the tank, the ECU repeats the process.
Marelli’s sensorless approach seemed promising, but
still the company got nowhere with automakers. “They
said it wouldn’t work,” Bonfiglioli recalls. “We had to
show them our demonstration vehicles.” That was in 2000.
It was only three years later that Volkswagen, in
Wolfsburg, Germany, decided to give it a shot. In March
2003, using Marelli’s flex-fuel system, the automaker
introduced the Gol TotalFlex, the first flex car in
Brazil.
That launch, combined with the Brazilian government’s
decision to give flex cars a tax break, spurred a
revolution in the country’s automotive industry. Other
big automakers rushed to announce their flex offerings,
and since then, sales of flex cars have skyrocketed. In
2003, they corresponded to only 3.5 percent of total
sales; now that share has risen to nearly 90 percent.
Marelli supplies its flex ECUs to Brazil’s largest
automakers, including Fiat, Ford, and Volkswagen, and it
has about 50 percent of that market, with the rest
divided between Bosch and Delphi Corp., in Troy, Mich.
“To some extent, what’s happening in terms of cars
being sold there is fairly directly attributable to the
capability that Marelli’s solution has provided,” says
Sharfman, the auto expert in New York City. “So if you
started to have an efficient source [of ethanol] here or
in some other country, I think that over time this kind
of solution is going to spread.”
You Tell Us which technologies will sink or swim
at
www.spectrum.ieee.org
Flex-fuel technology
has succeeded in Brazil mainly because
consumers saw a chance to save money. Because ethanol
comes from an agricultural product, its price varies
according to crop seasons. In October 2006 in southeast
Brazil, gasoline cost an average of $1.12 per liter and
ethanol was $0.63. You’ll go farther on 1 L of gasoline,
but in the end the cost per kilometer is still less
with ethanol. At 1000 km (621 miles) per month, flex
fuel could save the average driver around $200 per year.
“The Siena TetraFuel advances this flexibility one
step further,” says Marco Antonio Saltini, director of
government relations at Fiat in Brazil. “Consumers see a
chance to save even more using natural gas.”
Running on natural gas, whose cost per kilometer in
Brazil is less than half that of gasoline, someone who
drives more than 160 km per day can recover the
additional cost of the TetraFuel system in nine months
to a year, saving some $1095 annually, Saltini says. He
adds that implementing a natural gas system by
retrofitting would cost twice as much as doing the same
with the TetraFuel system.
Still, it’s a niche market. Fiat hopes to sell around
2500 Siena TetraFuel cars, currently priced at $19 124
each, this year. It’s a tiny fraction of the more than
half a million vehicles that Fiat’s Brazilian unit sold
in 2005. But Saltini notes that because the car can run
on pure gasoline, Fiat can sell it elsewhere in Latin
America. In fact, the automaker says the Siena TetraFuel
should hit the Argentinean market early this year.
The TetraFuel technology has interesting possibilities
in other markets as well. The European Union plans to
increase the share of biofuels in transportation to
5.75 percent by 2010, and many experts see a big push
toward E85, the 85 percent ethanol and 15 percent
gasoline blend. The same trend is occurring in a host of
other countries, including the United States, China,
India, and Japan.
And don’t forget about the TetraFuel’s ace in the
hole: its natural gas capability. Natural gas has
historically cost less than oil, and reserves are
plentiful, so it could work as another transitional fuel
if gasoline prices go up. There are already more than 5
million natural-gas vehicles around the world. Argentina
has a fleet of 1.5 million, and Brazil and Pakistan have
more than 1 million each. Other countries investing in
natural-gas cars include Iran, which has the world’s
second-largest natural gas reserve; Germany, which plans
to have more than 1000 natural-gas filling stations by
the end of the year; and France, which has a program to
let drivers fill up their natural-gas cars using home
refueling units.
Marelli is discussing with other automakers the use of
the technology outside Brazil, but the company declines
to provide any details. Could the TetraFuel become a hit
in Europe, Asia, or North America? Time will tell.
In the meantime, flex technology and ethanol could
make energy production more regionalized, with countries
producing biofuels where there’s arable land and
favorable weather. Different fuels would be available in
different places, and drivers wouldn’t have to worry
about it. “The idea is to have a multifuel car that runs
with the fuel it finds,” Bonfiglioli says.
“You can’t yet put water in,” he jokes. “But just wait.”
To learn more about engine control units, see
“Automotive Engine Control and Hybrid Systems:
Challenges and Opportunities,” by Andrea Balluchi et
al., in Proceedings of
the IEEE, Vol. 88, issue 7, July 2000,
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel5/5/18872/00871300.pdf.